Best Oven Cooking Trays 2021 | Top 5 Reviewed

Ever wondered what the best oven cooking tray is? You are not alone, this article was written to help you find the perfect oven cooking trays for your oven.

Everything definitely has an end. Though, time will vary. All ovens, be it electric convection or gas come with their own respective baking trays in them. These trays have individual composition which can assure you that they will last a lifetime. But, do they really last a lifetime?

If you are reading this, I’m sure you already know the answer to that, because that is what brought you here in the first place. Those trays are all rusted, old and stuff like that. Now, you need a new one.

Actually, that might not be the only reason why you need a new oven tray. It could be that the one that came with your oven is too small or too large for the purpose it is needed for. If it’s too small, then you might need a bigger one for domestic or commercial use.

For whichever or whatever purpose you are needing an oven tray for, the fact remains that you want something of great and first class quality. Now, you do not just see these top notch products flying over the net space. They are usually scarce.

These kind of trays are usually made with steel or aluminum. Why? It all draws down to the same reason. To increase the life span of the product. Since nothing can last forever, we can try our best to draw their life longer before they become useless.

Also, Aluminium and steel materials ensure that food or sticky objects do not actually stick to their surface. That is, they have little or no force of adhesion.

With this, you can bake food without having to pour flour or oil on the tray. We do this so the food doesn’t stick to the surface of the Bakeware. But, we can see it is not really necessary again. However, little of this might still be needed.

In addition, some of these quality items come on non stick coating. This is to help increase it’s opposition to forces of adhesion. Here, you don’t even have to use the oil or flour on the tray. The nonstick material does the cooking well and perfectly.

Another reason why non stick makes bakeware better is that since food doesn’t stick to the surface of the material, it makes it easy to wash. Sometimes, just a wipe with warm, soapy water will finish off the job.

Gone are those days when you will need to spend minutes scrubbing food leftovers off the baking tray. You would even have to leave some soaked in the water for hours before you could finally remove the stains from it.

Well, those days are gone. Thanks to the Introduction of Steel, Stainless steel, Aluminium and Non Stick coating in food technology. An amazing fact about these materials is that they are all good grade. This ensures that the element, compound or mixture used in the production of the material itself does not react with the food.

Let us end the chit chat and see what these baking pans really are. Well, you might be familiar with some of them and some might look entirely strange or new to you. Do not think it twice, go for it. They will be the perfect fit for you. Let’s go!

Best Oven Cooking Trays 2021

I have reviewed the top 5 oven cooking trays for your oven below, kindly check the pros, cons and features before purchasing.

1. Wilton Perfect Results Premium Non Stick 21 × 15 inch Mega Baking Pan

Product Information

Brand Name – Wilton

Manufacturer – Wilton Brands

Product Dimensions – 1.61 × 21.5 × 15.5 inches

Item Weight – 3.1 pounds

Model number – 2105-0109

Material Type – Steel

Colour – Metallic Silver


  • Product is made of 100% steel; non stick coating to ensure easy release of baked foods and quick clean up. This feature also increases its durability.
  • Comes with larger handles for better grip. This makes the pans easy to go in and out of the oven.
  • Comes with a 10 year warranty covering parts and labour.

Reasons to buy

  • Product allows you bake large batches of cookies, appetizers or other food very easily.
  • Product is 100% dishwasher safe, but hand washing in warm soapy water is recommended.
  • The pan is quite easy to clean.

Reason to avoid

  • The pan can not fit into smaller ovens.


2. Nordic Ware Natural Aluminium Commercial Bakers big sheet

Product Information

Brand Name – Nordic Ware

Manufacturer – Nordic Ware

Item dimensions – 21 × 15 × 1 inches

Material Type – Aluminium

Colour – Silver

Item weight – 2.06 pounds

Model Number – 44600AMZ


  • This baking pan is made of pure Aluminium which will never rust for a lifetime.
  • Has an extra large capacity for more food that of a standard sheet tray. This allows you bake more in each batch.
  • Product is compatible with parchment paper or silicone baking mats if desired.

Reasons to buy

  • The cooking tray, made of pure aluminium ensures that you achieve consistent evenly borrowed results every time you bake.
  • Products is very durable because pure aluminium does not rust.

Reasons to avoid

  • Baking tray is not non stick. This means there is a high probability that food items stick to the surface.
  • Item is not dishwasher safe, as continuous washing in a dishwasher can result in discolouration.


3. Calphalon Non Stick Bakeware, Baking Sheet , 2 piece set

Product Information

Brand Name – Calphalon

Manufacturer – Calphalon

Material Type – Steel

Colour – Silver

Size – 2 PC

Item dimensions – 12 × 17 × 1.5 inches

Item weight – 4.34 pounds

Model number – 1826034


  • Comes with a non stick surface, making it easy for food to be released without sticking to it.
  • This product is oven safe up to a temperature of 500°F. It cannot survive in an oven exceeding this temperature.
  • The Tray has a heavy gauge steel core to ensure all parts heat evenly without hotspots. This will improve the taste of your food.

Reasons to buy

  • Bakeware is dishwasher safe but hand washing is recommended for durability.
  • It is protected by Calphalon’s full lifetime warranty.
  • Has raised edges so you can bake with no spills in your oven.
  • Releases food up to 2X better than Calphalon Classic Bakeware.

Reason to avoid

  • Consistent use in dishwasher might affects its look and limit its lifespan.


4. Good Cook 08929002199 Non Stick Bakeware, Set of 3, Non Stick Cookie Sheet, Multicolour

Product Information

Brand Name – Good Cook

Manufacturer – BrahShaw International

Item dimensions – 19.6 × 12.6 × 6.8 inches

Material Type – Steel

Colour – Multi Colour

Size – Set of 3 Non Stick Cookie Sheet

Model number – 04322

Item Weight – 8.8 ounces


  • Item comes in small, medium, and large sizes that provide the perfect option for any of your baking needs.
  • Comes in a top quality non stick coating that removes the need for scrubbing and keeps it looking brand new.
  • Updates design for increased durability that allows for repeated use for years to come.

Reasons to buy

  • Non Stick coating makes it easy to clean
  • Does not react with food on the baking tray
  • 3 piece Bakeware makes it versatile for cooking. You can choose which size you want at any time.

Reason to avoid

  • Bakeware is not dishwasher safe.


5. Checkered Chef Baking Sheet and Rack Set. Aluminium Cookie sheet Tray/Half sheet Pan

Product Information

Brand Name – Checkered Chef

Manufacturer – Checkered Chef

Size – Single Tray and Rack

Material Type – Aluminium and Stainless Steel

Item dimensions – 17.95 × 1 × 13 inches

Item Weight – 2.54 pounds

Mod Number – 14187930


  • Has a sturdy, Aluminium construction of the checkered Chef half sheet pan gives it superior heat conductivity resulting in even baking with no burnt buttons.
  • Oven rack is made of 100% stainless steel with not artificial coatings or treatments.
  • Package secured in a box to ensure no dents or scratches occur during transits.

Reasons to buy

  • Baking Tray and Rack set makes cooking in the kitchen awesome and less stressful.
  • The two Bakeware are easy to clean up. Hand washing is recommended to enable it last longer.

Reason to avoid

  • No specific reason.


No doubt, you could step up your cooking game with these Bakeware mentioned above. Their descriptions and features will make you love them more that you will not even know which of them is the best. But, of course, you must choose one.

With these oven trays, you could get your friends or colleagues wondering what the secret to your delicious meat pie, or pizza is. Do not hesitate, tell them and let them know what is going on.

Be it domestic or commercial cooking, these Baking pans are the best for you. Most especially those ones that come in sets. They allow you arrange or select different pie depending on their sizes in the oven compartment.

However, we are not in any way affiliated with the manufacturers of these products so we do not guarantee they’ll deliver the acclaimed results. I have only made this post to show you some of these products which have been tested and trusted.

So, if at any time, anything goes wrong while using any of the products in this article, please refer to the manufacturers or brands themselves. They are in the best position to solve it for you. This also applies to the warranty of the products.

Leave a Comment